M

Scotch & Soda Barfly vs Новая Заря (The New Dawn) Shalilar

Scotch & Soda Barfly and Новая Заря (The New Dawn) Shalilar compared side by side: accords, longevity, sillage and value, so you can pick with confidence.

Scotch & Soda20124.4★BarflyChange
Новая Заря (The New Dawn)3.8★ShalilarChange

Very similar

How alike they smell

Pick Barfly formore Aromatic
Pick Shalilar formore Smoky, longer wear, stronger projection

Where they differ

BarflyShalilar
Projection
?
ProjectionHow far the scent radiates from your skin while you stand still. The 'sillage / projection' votes on fragrance pages blend the two, so read them as overall reach.More in Learn →
Shalilar is stronger
40
51
Longevity
?
LongevityHow long a fragrance lasts on skin. It depends on the ingredients, your skin, the weather and how much you spray, not only the concentration.More in Learn →
Shalilar lasts longer
53
63
Evening feelAbout the same
39
46
ValueShalilar is rated better value
66
86
Who it leans to
FeminineMasculine

What each smells more of
?
AccordA blend of notes the nose reads as one new smell, like a chord made of musical notes.More in Learn →

Which season

Spring
Summer
Fall
Winter

Together they get the most votes for Fall and Winter.

What's in them

Only in BarflyOrange · Cardamom · Anise · Pepper · Calone · Basil · Lavender · Nard Himalayan (Jatamansi)
Only in ShalilarBergamot · Patchouli · Rose · Leather
All the detailsPlain-word summary and every community vote

The difference in plain words

Barfly and Shalilar are very similar; both have Lemon, Mandarin Orange and Sandalwood. Barfly leans more aromatic, while Shalilar leans smoky. Shalilar lasts longer and projects more; it gets better value-for-money votes.

Time of day
day
night
Season
spring
summer
fall
winter
Value
way overpriced
overpriced
ok
good value
great value
Sillage
intimate
moderate
strong
enormous
Longevity
very weak
weak
moderate
long lasting
eternal
Gender
female
more female
unisex
more male
male

Made up your mind?

Barfly
Shalilar