Penhaligon's Elixir and Terry de Gunzburg Rose Infernale compared side by side: accords, longevity, sillage and value, so you can pick with confidence.
How alike they smell
Together they get the most votes for Fall and Winter.
Elixir and Rose Infernale are very similar; both have Turkey Red Rose and Incense. Elixir leans more woody, while Rose Infernale leans floral.