Fragonard Etoile vs Penhaligon's Lily of the Valley

Fragonard Etoile and Penhaligon's Lily of the Valley compared side by side: accords, longevity, sillage and value, so you can pick with confidence.

EtoileFragonard20094.1★

88% alikevs

Lily of the ValleyPenhaligon's19763.9★

The difference in plain words

Etoile and Lily of the Valley are very similar; both have Bergamot, Jasmine and Lily-Of-The-Valley. Etoile leans more fruity, while Lily of the Valley leans mossy. Etoile gets better value-for-money votes.

Longer lastingEtoile

Stronger projectionAbout the same

Better perceived valueEtoile

More of a night scentAbout the same

Accords

AccordA blend of notes the nose perceives as one unified smell - like a chord made of musical notes.More in Learn →

● Etoile ● Lily of the Valley

Both share: Bergamot · Jasmine · Lily-Of-The-Valley

Only in Etoile: Red Apple · Ginger · Gardenia · Virginia Cedar · Musk · Amber

Only in Lily of the Valley: Geranium · Amalfi Lemon · Ylang-Ylang · Rose · Oakmoss · Sandalwood

Community votes

Etoile ← · → Lily of the Valley

Time of day

day

night

Season

spring

summer

fall

winter

Value

way overpriced

overpriced

good value

great value

Sillage

intimate

moderate

strong

enormous

Longevity

very weak

weak

moderate

long lasting

eternal

Gender

female

more female

unisex

more male

male

Metrics

0–100, with delta

Longevity

LongevityHow long a fragrance lasts on skin.More in Learn →

Etoile +4

Sillage / projection

ProjectionHow far the scent radiates from your skin while you stand still. The 'sillage / projection' votes on fragrance pages blend the two, so read them as overall reach.More in Learn →

≈ even

Price valueEtoile +23

Night-nessLily of the Valley +3

Gender lean (♀→♂)

Feminine

Masculine

Etoile profile →Lily of the Valley profile →