M

Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco vs Parfums de Marly Carlisle

Carolina Herrera Mystery Tobacco and Parfums de Marly Carlisle compared side by side: accords, longevity, sillage and value, so you can pick with confidence.

Mystery TobaccoCarolina Herrera20164.4★
85% alikevs
CarlisleParfums de Marly20154.4★

The difference in plain words

Mystery Tobacco and Carlisle are very similar; both have Osmanthus, Patchouli and Tonka Bean. Mystery Tobacco leans more tobacco, while Carlisle leans fresh spicy. They last and project about the same.

Longer lastingCarlisle
Stronger projectionCarlisle
Better perceived valueAbout the same
More of a night scentMystery Tobacco

Accords

?
AccordA blend of notes the nose perceives as one unified smell - like a chord made of musical notes.More in Learn →
● Mystery Tobacco ● Carlisle
WoodyVanillaPatchouliSweetWarm SpicyFruityTobaccoFresh Spicy
Both share: Osmanthus · Patchouli · Tonka Bean
Only in Mystery Tobacco: Ginger · Citruses · Artemisia · Tobacco · Guaiac Wood · Vetiver
Only in Carlisle: Nutmeg · Green Apple · Saffron · Rose · Davana · Vanilla · Opoponax

Community votes

Mystery Tobacco ← · → Carlisle
Time of day
day
night
Season
spring
summer
fall
winter
Value
way overpriced
overpriced
ok
good value
great value
Sillage
intimate
moderate
strong
enormous
Longevity
very weak
weak
moderate
long lasting
eternal
Gender
female
more female
unisex
more male
male

Metrics

0–100, with delta
Longevity
?
LongevityHow long a fragrance lasts on skin.More in Learn →
Carlisle +7
70
77
Sillage / projection
?
ProjectionHow far the scent radiates from your skin while you stand still. The 'sillage / projection' votes on fragrance pages blend the two, so read them as overall reach.More in Learn →
Carlisle +7
56
63
Price value≈ even
33
33
Night-nessMystery Tobacco +5
71
66
Gender lean (♀→♂)
Feminine
Masculine
Mystery Tobacco profile →Carlisle profile →